MarketingDrafted 9:10Introduction·9 min leftHighlights onlyRegulatedDay 0
Resources / Blog

Business users and CCM

Marketing went self-serve. Why are regulated communications still waiting on IT?

Even at banks and insurers, business users are enabled to run their own marketing communications, but not their regulated communications. Let's look at why the two are handled differently, and what changes when they're given the same control.

·9 min read

Pencil sketch of a woman editing a document herself, beside a document of code lifted by a robotic arm connected to a server.
Short on time? Read the 30-second answer

Marketing communications moved to business users years ago, even in regulated firms, because a huge market demanded self-serve tools and marketers could prove what speed was worth. Regulated customer communications stayed with IT, measured on accuracy alone. Moving them to governed business ownership gets clearer communications to customers faster and frees IT for the systems only it can run.

Highlights only: you are reading the 60-second version. Switch it off at the top to read the full piece.
Try it

Guess first

Two quick guesses before you read. The answers show up where they appear in the piece.

Which email gets opened more often?

In 2024, how many financial promotions did the UK regulator have amended or withdrawn?

As you read, you'll find a marketing communication on the left and a regulated communication on the right. Let's follow them through the article and see the stages each one goes through and how long each one takes.As you read, the strip at the top follows a marketing communication and a regulated communication. Let's follow them through the article and see the stages each one goes through and how long each one takes.

A marketing team at an insurer can change a campaign subject line before lunch. The claims team in the same building has waited three weeks to change one sentence in a claim denial notice.

Same customers. Same brand. Often the same compliance function signing off on both.

And the message that waits is the one customers actually open.

45 to 65%
Open rate for emails about a customer's own account
21.5%
Average open rate for marketing emails

Mailchimp benchmarks, via Mailer To Go

So the communications that decide whether a customer stays, pays or complains are the hardest ones to change. That's a strange arrangement when you think about it.

Why do regulated communications sit with IT?

It's worth starting with the case for how things are, because it's a good one.

Ask a head of IT why regulated communications sit with them and you'll get a reasonable answer. A renewal notice carries regulatory obligations. It pulls live data from policy, billing and claims systems. Every notice has variants by product, state and language, and only developers can keep track of them all. One wrong clause goes to every customer in the run before anyone notices, and then you're running a remediation exercise.

There's history behind it too. Composition started as a print job. Policy data lived on the mainframe, statements ran in overnight batches and the output went straight to a print room. All of that belonged to IT. When print became PDF and PDF became email, ownership never moved.

If I had run operations at an insurer fifteen years ago, I would have made the same call.

Somewhere along the way, though, regulated communications became an IT asset and marketing emails became a business asset. Nobody decided that. It just stuck. Anyone in operations knows what it looks like day to day. You've probably seen the ticket:

TICKET #4471Priority: medium
Update para 3 of RNWL_TPL_v7 per legal's attached markup.

Document production started as an IT job, and ownership stayed put as print became PDF and email.

Why did marketing get there first?

Marketers edit their own emails, build their own landing pages and run their own journeys. So how did they end up with tools their own people could run, while operations didn't?

The biggest reason is what each team gets measured on.

Marketing is measured on what a message achieves: opens, clicks, conversions, revenue. So when marketers asked for speed, they could show what speed was worth. A campaign that ships a week earlier earns for a week longer. That's an easy budget conversation.

Operations is measured on whether the document went out correctly and on time. Did it carry the right clause? Did it reach the right customer? Did it meet the deadline? Those are the right checks for a regulated communication, but they only measure the risk of getting it wrong. Nobody measures what a confusing notice costs in calls, complaints or lapses, so nobody can show what a faster, clearer one would be worth.

EVIDENCEIn a review of 38 firms published in March 2026, the FCA found weak evidence that firms test their communications at all, and too much reliance on the absence of complaints as proof that customers understood.

In practice, the tools went to the team that could prove a return. Two other things helped marketing along.

The first is scale. Every company in every industry does marketing, and no marketer can wait on IT every time a campaign needs changing. Demand that broad was always going to be answered, and the software market answered it with email platforms, landing page builders and automation suites, all designed for the marketer to own. Once marketers ran their own platforms, they funded them too. Martech takes 19.4% of the marketing budget in 2026 . Operations has no equivalent line for its documents.

The second is how the technology grew up. Marketing software was designed for the marketer from the start. CCM took a different path.

GO DEEPERHow CCM software grew up⌄

Composition engines were built for developers: scripting, data mapping and designer tools that took weeks to learn. Vendors later added friendlier editors on top, but the core still assumed a technical operator. That history still shows in most CCM platforms today. The editor sits on top of a system that was built for someone else.

How the two kinds of customer communication are run today
Marketing communicationsRegulated customer communications
Measured onOpens, clicks, conversions, revenueCorrect and on time
Software designed forThe marketerThe developer
Who editsThe businessIT, through a ticket
Who approvesComplianceCompliance
Own budget lineMartech, 19.4% of marketing spendNone

Marketing is measured on what a message achieves, so it could prove what speed was worth.

Isn't this really about risk?

The usual objection is that marketing messages are low risk and regulated communications aren't. That's true, and it explains less than people think, because marketing in financial services is regulated too.

Myth or fact?
Marketing in banking and insurance can go out without compliance sign-off.

A credit card promotion or an investment ad needs compliance sign-off before it goes out. In 2024 alone, the FCA had 19,766 promotions amended or withdrawn.

19,766
Financial promotions amended or withdrawn after FCA intervention in 2024, up from 10,008 in 2023

Marketing still works self-serve. The marketer edits, compliance approves and it ships.

So regulation explains the approval step. What creates the ticket queue is that it merges two decisions marketing keeps apart: who approves a communication and who edits it.

Compliance approving every change makes sense. Having IT make every edit is a separate choice, and nobody really made it.

We've solved this once already, on the web. Nobody would accept a website where every copy change needs a developer ticket. Content management systems fixed that twenty years ago.

DEV2000EDITNOWWebsites solved this twenty years agoEvery copy changewaits for a developerThe people who own thewords now edit them
Websites moved the editing to the people who own the words. Regulated communications mostly haven't.

Regulated communications are still where websites were in 2000.

Join in
in

This piece is also running as a LinkedIn discussion. Share how long a wording change takes in your organization.

Join the discussion on LinkedIn →

Regulation explains why every change needs approval. The ticket queue comes from IT doing the editing.

Why hasn't operations pushed for the same?

If the case is that clear, why hasn't operations asked for it?

Part of the answer is what regulated communications are for. Their first job is to meet an obligation, so they're measured on accuracy, and outcomes come second if they come at all. That made sense for a long time. It's starting to change, but a few things hold the old model in place.

The CCM market itself isn't business friendly, whatever the brochures say. Most of the existing ecosystem is still built around a developer at the controls, so a business-run option was never really on the table.

The cost of slowness lands somewhere else. When a notice confuses people, the bill shows up in the contact center, in a budget that has no say over the notice.

??$When a notice confuses people, the cost lands somewhere elseA confusingnotice goes outCalls pile up inthe contact centerPaid from aseparate budget
A confusing notice goes out. The calls land in the contact center, in a budget that has no say over the notice.
Did you know?
84%

of companies in one billing survey said up to half of their inbound calls are about bills.

And the current system does its job. Documents go out. Audits pass. Teams can see that a business-user model would improve the process, but few have measured what it would do for customers, and fewer have proved the ROI. Moving off an IT-run setup takes real effort, and without a number attached, that effort is hard to justify.

It is moving at the leading edge, though. Aspire reports that more than half of digitally transformed enterprises have already shifted communications control from IT to the business.

Your notice is ready. It's just waiting its turn.Next release window: day 15.

Take a renewal, because it shows the whole problem in one document.

The retention team runs an email campaign around renewal season, with A/B-tested subject lines and a dashboard showing who opened and who clicked. The renewal notice itself, the document where the customer actually sees the new price, needs a ticket to change and goes out with no data coming back. It's also one of the most regulated documents an insurer sends. In the UK, firms have to tell customers at renewal whether the policy will auto-renew. Nobody knows whether the notice was read, let alone understood. And every confusing one shows up somewhere: in a call queue, in a complaint log or in a lapse.

It isn't only insurance. A health plan's wellness emails get tested and tracked. The explanation of benefits changes on IT's release calendar, even though in one survey 30% of consumers weren't sure whether it was a bill. The member who doesn't understand a partly paid claim calls the service line, and the service team has no way to fix the document that caused the call.

These documents can be measured. When the UK tax authority tested the wording of its payment reminder letters on more than 200,000 taxpayers, the most effective wording raised payment rates by 5.1 percentage points.

5.1 points
Rise in payment rates from rewording one tax reminder letter, tested on 200,000+ UK taxpayers (Hallsworth et al.)

The renewal notice probably matters more to retention than any campaign email, and it's the one message nobody measures.

The current setup does its job, the cost of slowness lands in another budget and nobody has put a number on the alternative.

What would business ownership actually look like?

Handing operations a marketing tool wouldn't work. Marketing automation was built for short-lived campaigns, and a regulated communication needs three things it doesn't do.

GO DEEPERThe three things a regulated communication needs⌄
  • A durable record. A fixed copy of exactly what each customer received, kept for years and reproducible on demand.
  • Real composition. A 40-page policy schedule where every clause, table and endorsement depends on that customer's data.
  • Mandatory content handled properly. Required wording stays in even when it tests poorly.

IT keeps an important role too. Much of a business's operational software should stay with IT. Policy administration, billing and process management are systems of record, and IT is right to own them. Customer communication is where the business talks to the customer, and the people who answer for that conversation should be able to run it.

That still means some things stay locked: data bindings to core systems, calculation logic, mandatory regulatory clauses and channel and delivery rules. Every edit needs an approval trail. Anyone selling this as Mailchimp for policy documents is underselling the risk.

412.00Customer dataCalculationsMandatory clauseWording, editedby the businessWhat the business edits, and what stays locked
Locked: customer data, calculations and mandatory clauses. Editable: the wording, with every change approved.

So where do you start?

WHERE TO START

The cleanest route is a platform built for business-user ownership, where operations edits, compliance approves and IT keeps control of the data. That's how we built Perfect Doc Studio.

See how it works →

Whatever the platform, the case has to stand on return. Faster changes and clearer communications for customers come first. Fewer tickets for IT come next. If you're not ready to invest yet, three things will build that case this quarter:

  1. Ask your service team which five documents generate the most calls.
  2. Time your last wording change, from legal sign-off to the first customer receiving it.
  3. Give each of those five documents a named business owner.

Moving these documents to the business gets clearer communication to customers sooner, and it gives IT its roadmap back. My guess is that the first operations teams to measure what their documents achieve will get their tools quickly.

Operations edits, compliance approves and IT keeps control of the data and the systems behind it.

Who in your organization can change one sentence in a regulated communication today, and how long does it take?

YOU'VE READ IT ALL

The one thing to take away: regulation explains why every change needs approval. The ticket queue comes from IT doing the editing, and that part can change.

After you read

Test what stuck.

Try it

Check yourself

Three quick questions. A wrong answer points you back to the section that covers it.

What is the biggest reason marketing got self-serve tools first?

What creates the ticket queue for wording changes?

What should stay locked when business users edit regulated communications?

Frequently asked questions

Why do regulated communications sit with IT?

Document production started as a print job on IT's systems: mainframe data, overnight batches and a print room. When print became PDF and then email, ownership stayed with IT.

Why did marketing get self-serve tools before operations?

Marketing is measured on outcomes, so it could prove what speed was worth, and its market was broad enough for vendors to build self-serve tools for it. Regulated communications grew up inside IT and are measured on accuracy.

Is keeping regulated communications with IT about risk?

Regulation explains why every change needs compliance approval, and marketing in financial services works under the same kind of rules. The ticket queue comes from IT doing the editing, which is a separate choice that can change.

Why hasn't operations pushed for business ownership of regulated communications?

The current setup does its job, the cost of slow or confusing communications shows up in another budget such as the contact center, and few teams have put a number on what a clearer document would be worth.

Can business users safely edit regulated customer communications?

Yes, when the platform locks data bindings, calculation logic and mandatory clauses, and every edit goes through compliance approval with an audit trail.

What should stay locked in a regulated communication template?

Data bindings to core systems, calculation logic, mandatory regulatory clauses and channel and delivery rules.

How long should a regulatory wording change take to go live?

With governed business editing, days. In ticket-based models it often takes weeks, because each change passes through several handoffs and waits for a release window.

Hari Krishnan
Hari KrishnanProduct Marketing Manager, Perfect Doc Studio

Writes about regulated communications, CCM and their growing role in customer experience.

Connect on LinkedIn