Guess first
Two quick guesses before you read. The answers show up where they appear in the piece.
Of the Medicaid coverage losses CMS expects, what share does it put down to procedural reasons such as missed paperwork?
Under the rule, when does a member count as having received a notice?
Picture a home health aide who works shifts for two agencies. In March, an envelope from the state Medicaid office arrives with the rest of the mail. It asks her to show that she works at least 80 hours a month, and it gives her 30 days to reply.
She does work those hours. Her shifts are split across two employers, so the payroll data the state checked did not add up to 80. The envelope ends up under a coffee mug on the kitchen table, and the weeks pass.
If she doesn't reply in time, she loses her coverage, even though she met the requirement all along.
From January 1, 2027, millions of Medicaid members will receive notices like this one. CMS expects about 2.3 million people to lose coverage in fiscal year 2027, and it attributes nearly 43% of those losses to procedural reasons, such as a reply that never came.
For those members, the notice will decide the outcome as much as the rule does.
What actually changes on January 1?
Supporters see the requirement as a way to link public coverage to work and community involvement. Critics expect many people who qualify to lose coverage along the way. This piece takes no side on the policy. It looks at the regulated communications that will carry it to members.
The rule applies to adults aged 19 to 64 in the Medicaid expansion group, in 43 states and Washington, DC. About 20 million people were enrolled through expansion as of June 2025. To keep coverage, they need 80 hours a month of work, community service, a work program or half-time study, or monthly income of at least 80 times the federal minimum wage, which is $580 in 2026.
States check compliance when people apply and when they renew, and they may check more often. Most states start on January 1, 2027. A few started earlier, including Nebraska in May and Montana in July, and Iowa begins on December 1.
GO DEEPERWho is exempt from the requirement⌄
- Parents and caretakers of a child aged 13 or under, or of a person with a disability
- People who are medically frail
- Pregnant and postpartum individuals
- Veterans with a total disability rating
- American Indians and Alaska Natives, and former foster youth
- People who already meet SNAP or TANF work requirements, and people in drug or alcohol treatment
Readiness is uneven. Colorado has been unable to check work and health status automatically for at least 175,000 adults. New Jersey expects its systems work to continue through 2027. In Indiana, North Carolina and Idaho, state law sets a three-month lookback that can't change before legislatures meet in January. The rules themselves are still moving: on October 29, a federal judge struck down CMS's stricter definition of medical frailty.
From January 1, 2027, adults in Medicaid expansion must show work or an exemption, in states that are not equally ready, under rules that are still changing.
Why will a notice decide who stays covered?
Every state starts with the data it already holds: payroll records, SNAP and TANF files, Medicaid claims. States expect that data to confirm 60% to 80% of current enrollees. The rest, 20% to 40% of the people subject to the rule, will hear from the state in writing.
When a state cannot confirm someone, it must send a notice and give them 30 calendar days to show they comply or qualify for an exemption. Members keep their coverage while the window runs. Once the data runs out, a single notice and a 30-day window carry the whole decision.
Arkansas ran a work requirement in 2018, and more than 18,000 people lost coverage in less than a year. Avalere Health and Command Direct, drawing on evaluations of that program, report that most people who missed their renewal never knew the window was open.
That is the risk teams are preparing for now. A member who qualifies but never reads the notice looks, on the state's records, exactly like a member who doesn't qualify.
When the data can't confirm a member, the notice and its 30-day window decide whether an eligible person keeps coverage.
What should member communications teams do before January 1?
State Medicaid agencies send the legal notices. Health plans hold the member relationship: the phone number that works, the app the member opens and the care manager they trust. Plans can add their own outreach around each state notice. The teams on both sides can act on five things.
- Match each notice to the member.
- Write it so members can act on it.
- Send it on more than one channel.
- Keep a record of every notice.
- Be ready to change the wording fast.
1. Match each notice to the member
Members do not face the same risk. Avalere Health and Command Direct sort them into three groups by how likely they are to be exempt. For someone likely to be exempt, the exemption should be on file before any compliance notice goes out. For someone whose case depends on how severe their condition is, the notice needs reminders and help. For someone unlikely to be exempt, it needs plain steps on what to report, by when and how.
One notice written for everyone fails all three groups in different ways. The warning sign is a single template with the member's name merged in and nothing else changed.
2. Write it so members can act on it
The action, the deadline and the consequence belong at the top of the first page, in plain words. The notice should be available in the languages the plan's members read and in accessible digital formats. The Arkansas notices were written at about an eighth-grade reading level. The warning sign is a deadline that first appears in the third paragraph.
3. Send it on more than one channel
The law already expects this for outreach: states send it by mail, or electronically if the member chose that, and through at least one other channel such as phone, text or a portal message. Plans can build on it with a planned sequence across the 30 days, where each missed touch triggers the next one. About a third of Arkansas enrollees had changed their phone number or address, according to the same commentary. The warning sign is returned mail that sits in a tray with no next step.
4. Keep a record of every notice
For each member, the team should be able to show which approved version they were sent, when and through which channel. That record supports appeals and state oversight, and it tells the team who needs the next touch. The Arkansas commentary puts the cost of skipping it plainly: non-receipt looked like noncompliance. The warning sign is a notice program that can say what went out in total but not what one member received.
5. Be ready to change the wording fast
The October 29 court ruling changed the medical frailty standard two months before launch, and more guidance from CMS and the states will follow. A notice approved in November may need new wording in February. Teams that can update a notice in days, with compliance approval on record, will keep pace with the rule as it settles. The warning sign is a wording change that waits weeks in a development queue.
How ready are your notices?
Tick what your team can do today. Each one you tick clears a ring from the envelope.
0 of 5 in place
Start with the first gap: match each notice to the member.
Matching, plain wording, several channels, a record of every notice and fast changes give eligible members the best chance of replying in time.
What can better notices not fix?
The strongest objection deserves a straight answer. By CMS's own estimate, most of the expected losses come from people not meeting the requirement as the agency models it, and no notice changes who qualifies. Some states are short on data and time, and a well-written notice cannot fill a gap in a payroll file. Critics of the policy will also say that smoother notices make a flawed rule run more quietly.
All of that is fair. What notices can change is the procedural share: the eligible member who never saw the envelope, could not follow it or missed the date. On CMS's numbers, that is nearly 43% of the losses it expects.
When coverage depends on a reply, the notice has to work for the member who is busiest, least online or least sure what it means.
Medicaid is the sharpest current case of a pattern that reaches well beyond it. When a bank's reply to a hardship request or an insurer's claim notice decides whether a customer keeps a benefit, the same five actions apply.
GO DEEPERWhat is still unknown before January 1⌄
- Response rates: no state has yet published how many members answer a compliance notice in time.
- Court cases: a second lawsuit over the rule is pending in Maryland.
- State changes: legislatures with fixed lookback periods meet again in January.
- Guidance: CMS has offered states mitigation options, such as self-attestation, and more guidance is expected.
The first months of 2027 will show which states and plans got this right. Watch the share of members who reply within the 30 days, and how many lost coverage and later re-enrolled.
Better notices cannot change who qualifies, but they can protect the eligible members who would otherwise lose coverage over paperwork.
How does Perfect Doc Studio support these five actions?
We built Perfect Doc Studio, a customer communications management platform for regulated enterprises, so operations teams can change the wording of their regulated communications, compliance can review and approve in the same workflow and IT keeps control of the data and integrations. Here is how it lines up with the five actions.
- Right version for each member: templates are designed with data variables and authored once for delivery across channels, so one approved notice can be tailored for each member group.
- Words members can act on: more than 108 languages, with AI contextual translation that uses language-specific wording, and an accessibility optimizer that helps make notices accessible.
- More than one channel: print and mail run inside the same workflow as digital delivery, and notices can also go out by SMS and WhatsApp.
- A record of every notice: versioning and audit control keep a record of every change, and approval routing sends every change for review before it reaches members.
- Ready to change fast: business teams change wording without waiting on a development cycle, and a wording change can move in days, with every step on record.
Developer support is still needed to set up integrations with core systems, such as eligibility data, and to configure workflows specific to each operation.
Bring one member notice, and we will show you how it would run as matched versions across mail and digital channels, with every change on record.
Book a walkthrough →If one of your members gets this notice in March, what will make them open it, understand it and reply within 30 days?
The one thing to take away: under Medicaid work requirements, the notice decides whether many eligible members keep coverage, and teams have until January 1 to make it work.

